Justice Department Calls Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's Structure Unconstitutional

20 March, 2017, 11:18 | Author: Oscar Goodwin
  • President Donald Trump

Cordray has said he would not step down, and some legal scholars have said the ongoing case could present problems for Mr. Trump if he tried to remove Cordray.

On Friday the Justice Department opposed the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau in a court case, calling the independent consumer regulator's structure unconstitutional.

The CFPB is in the midst of a fight to keep its structure, which keeps the bureau's director protected from political interference, the The Wall Street Journal reports.

"There is a greater risk that an "independent" agency headed by a single person will engage in extreme departures from the President's executive policy", the brief reads.

The department also said that because CFPB directors hold five-year terms, a president may not get a chance to appoint someone who agrees with him. This would likely benefit President Trump, who has expressed a desire to replace current director Richard Cordray with someone who might be more business-friendly.

But Democrats and consumer advocates said a commission would make the bureau less effective. It's unclear how the court will rule. The agency says it has delivered $11.7 billion of "relief to consumers" since its creation, including $3.6 billion in direct compensation to consumers and $7.7 billion in principal reductions, canceled debts and other consumer relief.

The Democratic-controlled 111th Congress created the CFPB as part of the Dodd-Frank Act in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis. The director's term being five years was another complication. But critics, including Republican legislators, say they give the agency, and its director, too much power.

Instead, the Justice Department could only file a brief supporting the CFPB's opponent, mortgage company PHH Corp. Mr. Cordray, the CFPB director, took a more critical view of the violation, and imposed a $109 million sanction.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Washington, D.C., circuit ruled in October that the CFPB's structure is unconstitutional.

The United States limits its brief to the issue of whether the limitations on the President's removal authority recognized by the U.S. Supreme Court in Humphrey's Executor v. U.S., 295 U.S. 602 (1935), apply beyond multi-member regulatory commissions to an agency headed by a single Director.

The Trump administration Friday officially joined a legal challenge aimed at sharply reducing the authority of a federal consumer watchdog that has drawn praise and criticism for cracking down on mortgage abuses, banking irregularities, and other alleged financial wrongdoing. But the CFPB will be fighting that battle without the backing of the DOJ.

But while the DOJ's brief will likely be taken seriously, the outcome of the appeal is uncertain. Oral arguments are set to begin May 24.

Recommended:

  • Mayo Clinic questioned after CEO says private insurance should be 'prioritized'

    Mayo Clinic questioned after CEO says private insurance should be 'prioritized'

    As Human Services commissioner, Piper is focused on ensuring access to health care for those enrolled in public programs. However, Noseworthy wanted the employees to apply discretion when two patients are referred with similar conditions.
    What to expect from Neil Gorsuch's confirmation hearings

    What to expect from Neil Gorsuch's confirmation hearings

    Some Democratic senators - such as Oregon's Jeff Merkley - have spoken out forcefully against him, but most have not. He's met with upward of 70 senators and rehearsed disarming answers in private "murder boards".
    Israel warns Syria after exchange of fire

    Israel warns Syria after exchange of fire

    Israeli denied that any planes had been hit, but it did say "several antiaircraft missiles" were fired following the raid. He said he believed Assad responded more strongly this time because he feels increasingly confident.
  • YouTube on the defensive after new restrictions on some LGBTQ content

    YouTube on the defensive after new restrictions on some LGBTQ content

    YouTube got itself in trouble over the weekend after users discovered that the Restricted Mode feature is hiding LGBTQ+ content. Despite complaints from the LGBT community, it's clear that restricted mode isn't specifically targeting queer content.
    Nittany Lions To Face Union In First Ever NCAA Tournament Game

    Nittany Lions To Face Union In First Ever NCAA Tournament Game

    Despite Penn State's short varsity history, this will not be the first meeting with Union. Union fell 4-1 to Cornell in the ECAC Tournament on Friday night.
    Erdogan urges parliament to bring back death penalty

    Erdogan urges parliament to bring back death penalty

    Turkey's threats don't stop there. "Those who cross the line cannot assume that they can propagate their political views here". The last-minute cancellation indicates tempers could get hotter and the Turkish-German relationship perhaps even cooler.
  • Syria fires missiles at Israeli jets after airstrikes

    Syria fires missiles at Israeli jets after airstrikes

    The National Defense Force, a pro-regime militia set up in 2012, claimed the man killed was from among their ranks. The group published four pictures it said were from the scene of the alleged airstrike.
    How Trump's budget cuts could hurt low-income Americans

    How Trump's budget cuts could hurt low-income Americans

    The value of military spending was underscored by the announcement of a big Navy contract for a NY company. The market has boomed since Trump's election, a plus for the state treasury.
    Aguero's goal rescues City from defeat

    Aguero's goal rescues City from defeat

    City are now two points behind second-placed Tottenham, with Liverpool a point further back in fourth, having played a game more . City looked to spread the ball into the wide positions to attack the more forward-thinking Milner and Nathaniel Clyne .
  • Trump, with Merkel, on wiretapping:

    Trump, with Merkel, on wiretapping: "at least we have something in common"

    As of 2014, NATO's collective agreement directed members to spend 2 percent of their GDP on defense spending by 2024. In January, Trump called Merkel's open-door refugee policy a "catastrophic mistake." I didn't make an opinion on it.
    Beauty and the Beast enchants with record North American opening

    Beauty and the Beast enchants with record North American opening

    Josh Gad plays Gaston's sidekick, LeFou, who has a very brief "exclusively gay moment", as Condon described it, late in the film. For these reasons and more, it's not entirely surprising that the film had a record breaking opening weekend at the box office.
    India finished 3rd day by scoring 360 runs

    India finished 3rd day by scoring 360 runs

    As Pujara and Saha applied the sleeper hold in Ranchi, Australia also attempted to play the long game. Proceedings on the last day of the Test at Ranchi looked a bit grim for the visitors from the onset.


Popular

Showers and warmer temperatures ahead
The chance of rain continues for Wednesday but right now it doesn't appear as if it will be all that heavy or last for very long. After a chilly morning with temperatures in the low 30s, Monday is looking to be the warmest day of this coming week.

Erik Spoelstra Offers Update on Status of Dion Waiters
The turnaround for the Heat this season is nothing short of phenomenal, but the team still has plenty of work to go. Ricky Rubio had 20 points for Minnesota. "It's unfortunate", Spoelstra said.

In budget, Trump puts military over diplomacy
And, to be sure the $54 billion in non-defense cuts he put forth are matched by $54 billion in defense spending increases. There are small cuts elsewhere, mostly in places where there are surely ways to streamline and better utilize funding.

Man United on the up as Fellaini strikes
The win saw United climb into the Premier League's top five for the first time since September. They share the division's best defensive away record with Chelsea, conceding just 12 goals.

Duterte Says He's Not Intimidated by Impeachment Attempt
It is the first impeachment try against the President before a Congress dominated by his allies. Meanwhile, 2,500 of these fatalities were attributed to "legitimate police operations".